Annoyingly Different
Wednesday, May 23rd, 2007I lost my cell phone a while ago. It was a recent-model Nokia and I replaced it with another recent-model Nokia slightly different than the lost one.
I was quite surprised to find many small differences in the interface. Many of the menus were subtly different for no apparent reason. In some cases, the phone was worse, in other cases, better.
In my old phone, if I wanted to change the current ring profile (for example, to switch to silent or vibrate-only), I could hit the power button and I’d get a menu that included all the profiles. In my new phone, the power button doesn’t do anything like that. There’s a “Go to” menu mapped to the left soft-key that allows me to pick either the “normal” or “silent” profile (among a million other options) but doesn’t reveal the other ring profiles. If I want to switch to “meeting” or “vibrate”, I need to navigate many levels into the main menu.
On the other hand, the new phone has dedicated volume buttons on the side, which the other phone lacked. I always wondered how Nokia missed those — aren’t they mandatory for a mobile phone?
So, what’s up, Nokia? Is this an example of the constant iteration and tweaking you do on your handsets? Did you make these subtle changes for a good reason or just because different teams designed the two phones?